Consumer Mattress
We compare the best mattresses so you can find your best night’s sleep.
The Top 10
Mattress Brands of 2025
Swap confusing visits to multiple review sites with our expertly-curated Top 10 mattress guide.
1
Puffy
12,500+ Reviews
From $349, 0% Financing.
SAVE $1,500
2
Tempur-Pedic
1,700+ Reviews
From $4,099, 0% Financing.
SAVE $0
3
Leesa
100+ Reviews
From $1,424, 0% Financing.
SAVE 25%
4
Sleep Number
51,500+ Reviews
From $2,449, 0% Financing.
SAVE 50%
5
Amerisleep
500+ Reviews
From $1,599, 0% Financing.
SAVE $500
6
Helix
5,600+ Reviews
From $1,030, 0% Financing.
SAVE 25%
7
Saatva
100+ Reviews
From $2,945, 0% Financing.
SAVE $350
8
Purple
2,000+ Reviews
From $2,749, 0% Financing.
SAVE $500
9
Nectar
2,000+ Reviews
From $1,099, 0% Financing.
SAVE $550
10
Dreamcloud
800+ Reviews
From $949, 0% Financing.
SAVE 50%
Our Mattress Testing Methods
We pride ourselves on our thorough, evidence-based testing methodology.
-
Temperature Testing
We test the thermoregulation properties of every mattress with advanced thermal sensor technology. This allows us to measure how well a mattress can dissipate heat and how it would perform in real life to keep sleep cool and comfortable for an extended period of time. Temperature testing is a cornerstone of our testing process, so you can trust our results to guide you toward a cool and refreshing sleep experience.
-
Pressure Relief
When we test the pressure relief capabilities of a mattress, we look at how effectively it distributes weight and alleviates pressure on the body’s key pressure points. To do this we use advanced pressure mapping technology to visualize those areas of high pressure, focusing on the hips, shoulders, and back, which are problem areas for many sleepers. Our detailed assessment helps you identify mattresses that minimize aches and discomfort, rather than amplify them.
-
Firmness Testing
Firmness varies significantly from one mattress to another. In our firmness testing, we use various weights to simulate different body types and examine how the mattress responds. This helps us evaluate the comfort and support it offers to a variety of potential users, and ensure that our mattress recommendations are relevant to a diverse spectrum of sleep styles and preferences.
-
Motion Isolation
In our motion isolation testing, we simulate sleep disturbances and examine the extent of motion transfer from one side of the mattress to the other. This allows us to assess a mattress’ ability to provide a calm, undisturbed sleep environment. Our thorough motion isolation testing means Consumer Mattress recommendations meet the highest standards for peaceful, undisturbed sleep.
How to Buy
a Luxurious Quality Mattress Online.
In 9 Simple Steps.
Purchasing a mattress online is increasingly popular for good reason. It’s incredibly convenient to research, compare, and order a mattress from the comfort of your own home, but finding the perfect fit from so many available options can be a bit overwhelming.
At Consumer Mattress, we know the essential features that separate a luxurious mattress from the rest. As you weigh up your options, pay attention to the 10 essential factors we highlight in our comparison guides:
1. Mattress Type
The first step in buying a mattress online is to familiarize yourself with the various types of mattresses available. While there are many materials and designs, the most common types include:
Memory Foam
Known for their contouring feel and pressure-relief properties, memory foam mattresses are an excellent choice for those with chronic pain.
Innerspring
These traditional mattresses use a system of metal coils to provide support and are typically firmer and bouncier.
Hybrid
Combining the best of both worlds, hybrid mattresses incorporate a layer of memory foam or latex over an innerspring system, offering a blend of support and comfort.
Latex
These mattresses are made from natural or synthetic latex and offer a more responsive and bouncy feel compared to memory foam, with the added benefit of being hypoallergenic and eco-friendly.
2. Sleep Position and Firmness
Everyone has a preferred sleep position – side, back, stomach, or a combination. Identifying yours will help you choose the right firmness level for your mattress. Here's a general guideline:
Side sleepers: A medium to soft mattress can provide excellent pressure relief for your hips and shoulders.
Back sleepers: A medium-firm to firm mattress is ideal for back sleepers, as it offers adequate lumbar support and maintains a neutral spine.
Stomach sleepers: A firmer mattress is recommended to prevent excessive sinking and keep the spine aligned.
3. Quality Materials
When shopping for a luxurious quality mattress, pay close attention to the materials used, thickness, and layer composition. A premium mattress should have:
- High-density foam or latex layers for durability and support.
- Cooling features, such as gel-infused memory foam or breathable covers, for temperature regulation.
- Reinforced edges to prevent sagging and provide a consistent sleep surface.
4. Trial Period, Warranty, and Return Policies
One of the significant advantages of buying a mattress online is the availability of trial periods, which allow you to test out the mattress in your own home for a specified duration (usually 100 nights or more).
Ensure the mattress you choose has a risk-free trial period, minimum ten-year warranty, and a hassle-free return policy.
5. Reviews and Testimonials
Gathering insights from others who have purchased the same mattress can be incredibly helpful. Keep in mind that individual preferences and experiences may vary, so it's essential to read multiple reviews to get a comprehensive understanding.
6. Look for Certifications and Endorsements
When investing in a luxurious quality mattress, ensure that it meets industry standards and certifications. Look for:
- CertiPUR-US® certification for foam mattresses, which guarantees that the foam is free from harmful chemicals and has low VOC emissions for indoor air quality.
- For latex mattresses, look for the OEKO-TEX® Standard 100 certification, ensuring that the materials are free from harmful substances.
- Endorsements from reputable organizations, such as the American Chiropractic Association or the International Chiropractic Association.
7. Shipping and Delivery Options
Many online mattress companies offer free shipping and delivery within the contiguous United States. Be sure to check the shipping and delivery options available for your chosen mattress, as well as any additional fees that may apply.
8. Discounts and Promotions
Online mattress retailers frequently offer promotions, discounts, or bundle deals that can save you a significant amount of money on your purchase. Keep an eye out for these offers - we highlight any notable ones we find when researching mattresses for our Top 10 Mattresses.
9. Customer Support
A responsive and helpful customer support team sets luxury mattress providers apart from the rest. Choose a company with excellent customer service to ensure that you receive assistance and guidance throughout the process, from pre-purchase inquiries to post-purchase concerns or returns.